Showing posts with label choosing and documenting sources. Show all posts
Showing posts with label choosing and documenting sources. Show all posts

Friday, May 25, 2007

Quote Week Ends With Famous Non-Quotes


A lot of famous quotes are attributed to the wrong people, or were never even "spoken" by anyone in the first place. Today: some examples.

"There are three kinds of lies: Lies, damn lies, and statistics." Most people attribute this quote to Mark Twain, but he didn't say it. He repeated it, though, and gave credit to the person who DID originally say it: Benjamin Disraeli.

Business students: Don't claim President Bush said, "The problem with the French is that they don't have a word for entrepreneur." President Bush has said many things, but not that.

Did Chief Seattle ever say, "The earth is our mother"? He did not. If you have a Chief Seattle quote in your paper, you better track down the original source, because there are a number of ecology-based quotes attributed to him that he never actually said.

Despite the jokes about it, Al Gore never claimed to have "invented the Internet."

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle never had Sherlock Holmes say the line, "Elementary, my dear Watson." (In a later film version of a Sherlock Holmes story, though, the film Holmes did say something close to that.)

We could go on, but the lesson is simple: document your sources. Even if you want to use a "famous" quote that you're sure the source said, because everyone says that the source said that, remember that if you're writing for college, you better track the quote down and cite your source.

Good weekend to you.

Friday, March 9, 2007

With So Many Sources to Choose From, What's a Writer to Do?

As a last post for this week where we've talked about sources and how to judge their reliability, we should also mention that even among reliable sources there are varying degrees of credibility. The magazine US Weekly, for instance, might report some accurate information about a star's movie deal, but the same information reported in The New York Times will carry more weight when used as a source in an academic paper. This may not be right. It may not be fair.

But usually it is. Certain publications have greater demands for accuracy than others, and therefore greater credibility. Even if in an individual instance there's no difference in the information between two sources, US Weekly probably reports more not-quite-true stuff in its pages than The New York Times does.

So some things to think about:

There is a huge variety of types of sources: book, periodical, scholarly journal, magazine, broadcast, visual, electronic media, etc.

It may seem obvious, but you should ask yourself what type of source it is. Is it print, electronic, or visual media? Defining the source may help determine its credibility. Where did you find it – at the library, in a bookstore, on television, in a museum, or on the Internet? Maybe you want to use a visual or audio source, such as a film, a painting, or a recording (symphony, song). As every source is different, remember to research the source itself.

For instance, if you use a journal, periodical, or a magazine, determine if the journal or periodical is scholarly, academic, or simply a mainstream, popular culture magazine. As we noted, there exist various levels of complexity and clarity in conveyance of ideas and information. The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) differs greatly from People Magazine.

There aren't hard and fast rules--you may, in certain situations, be able to use People Magazine as a source of information. But there are sound guidelines and problems to be aware of when doing research for an academic paper, and it's good to keep them in mind.

Wednesday, March 7, 2007

Wikipedia! Or: Sometimes Things Didn't Happen, and Some People Don't Exist

For many students, when sitting at a computer and thinking about doing some research, the first stop is Wikipedia, the popular online encyclopedia. It has tons of information on tons of topics. It's fast and easy. So why, when you are asked to do a research paper in classes at school, do professors often forbid you from using Wikipedia as a source? Are they totally behind the times? Are they paranoid of how cool the Internet is? Are they grumpy about how easy it is to do research these days, seeing as how they probably spent entire days in libraries before Wikipedia came along?

It's possible, depending on the age and grumpiness of your particular professor, that the answer to some of those questions above is yes. But there are also many extremely GOOD REASONS that Wikipedia is not considered a reliable source.

Let us say, for instance, that you're doing a research paper on the cartoon Tom & Jerry, and let us say that when you look at Wikipedia, it says there was once an episode of Tom & Jerry in which Tom had too much to drink and bought a huge amount of Brady Bunch memorabilia on eBay. And let us say that you mention this in your essay, citing Wikipedia as your source for this information.

Now your professor might suspect that this information is inaccurate. A good thing about Wikipedia is that the entries are monitored by people, so there are probably people at Wikipedia who will see that entry and also suspect it is inaccurate. Here is what could happen:

1. Someone who uses or works for Wikipedia could challenge that information. They could say that they doubt this Tom & Jerry episode ever actually existed, and they suspect someone made this up.
2. The people who manage Wikipedia could decide that the episode of Tom & Jerry didn't actually exist, and could delete that information from the entry.
3. Your professor, looking up your source, could read the entry for Tom & Jerry and not see a single thing there about the Tom & Jerry episode about drinking, the Brady Bunch, and eBay.
4. Your professor could ask you to please show her where you got that information.
5. You could go onto Wikipedia, look up the exact entry where you got the information, and find...it's gone.
6. And now you are not feeling so good, and everyone is confused. Was there ever a Tom & Jerry episode about eBay? Was there ever a Wikipedia entry that referred to a Tom & Jerry episode about eBay? If there was an episode, when was it made and aired? If there was a Wikipedia entry, when was it published, and when was it changed? It's possible to try and track down the answers to some of these questions, but it's not easy, and it's not fun, and wouldn't you rather be doing something else?
7. Even more confusing: everyone who adds text to or subtracts text from entries on Wikipedia uses a user name. In other words, we only know the writers and editors by aliases, and often have no idea who these people really are.

This is why, in a research paper, Wikipedia is not considered a reliable source.

Consider this: The New Yorker magazine, which employs vigilant fact-checkers on its articles, wrote an article about Wikipedia last year. In it, they quoted a Wikipedia site administrator who went by the user name of Essjay. He was responsible for overseeing the accuracy of site content. According to The New Yorker, he told them he was “a tenured professor of religion at a private university” with “a Ph.D. in theology and a degree in canon law.” His degrees and knowledge were, theoretically, why he was someone entrusted with monitoring the accuracy of the site. It has recently come to light, though, that this person is NOT a professor. He doesn't even have any advanced degrees. He is twenty-four years old and has never taught anything.

This person, by the way, is still employed by Wikipedia. The co-founder of Wikipedia, according to The New Yorker, said about this person's fake name and credentials, “I regard it as a pseudonym and I don’t really have a problem with it.”

Wikipedia might be a place to START looking for information and for other sources about a topic. But due to situations like those above, most professors don't consider Wikipedia itself to be a credible source. They would prefer that you use articles written by people who use their real names, and which are edited and published by people who use their real names--articles that don't suddenly change or vanish overnight.