skip to main |
skip to sidebar
A lot of famous quotes are attributed to the wrong people, or were never even "spoken" by anyone in the first place. Today: some examples.
"There are three kinds of lies: Lies, damn lies, and statistics." Most people attribute this quote to Mark Twain, but he didn't say it. He repeated it, though, and gave credit to the person who DID originally say it: Benjamin Disraeli.
Business students: Don't claim President Bush said, "The problem with the French is that they don't have a word for entrepreneur." President Bush has said many things, but not that.
Did Chief Seattle ever say, "The earth is our mother"? He did not. If you have a Chief Seattle quote in your paper, you better track down the original source, because there are a number of ecology-based quotes attributed to him that he never actually said.
Despite the jokes about it, Al Gore never claimed to have "invented the Internet."
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle never had Sherlock Holmes say the line, "Elementary, my dear Watson." (In a later film version of a Sherlock Holmes story, though, the film Holmes did say something close to that.)
We could go on, but the lesson is simple: document your sources. Even if you want to use a "famous" quote that you're sure the source said, because everyone says that the source said that, remember that if you're writing for college, you better track the quote down and cite your source.
Good weekend to you.
Quote week turned into two weeks. That's cool with us if it's cool with you. We thought about acknowledging that in the title, but "Quote Fortnight" just doesn't have the same punch. So last week was quote week, and this week, too, is quote week. Right? Right.
When writing a paper with quoted sources, don't be afraid to utilize diverse sentence structures. Consider the following variations of the same quote:
a. "What is known can seldom be immediately told, and when it might be told, it is no longer known," writes Johnson on the subject of biography (116).
b. About biography, Johnson writes that "what is known can seldom be immediately told" (116), thus expressing both his discretions and his desire for intimate knowledge.
c. In the Life of Addison, Johnson further acknowledges the biographer's difficulties: "What is known can seldom be immediately told, and when it might be told, it is no longer known" (116).
d. "What is known," Johnson writes, "can seldom be immediately told, and when it might told, it is no longer known" (116).
Now: you could vary your constructions randomly, and it might work fine. More advanced writers, of course, report having a "sense" (or sometimes a "rhythm") that tells them which of the possible constructions follows smoothly from the previous sentence, or leads smoothly to the following sentence. The criteria for those kinds of decisions are complex and the subject of opinion. What we can say with certainty, though, is that if you use the exact same construction for every sentence in which you quote someone, many readers become bored. So why not switch it up?
We're talking this week about effectively using quotes in research papers. Today, our suggestion is to make sure that rather than sprinkling quotes into your paper in isolated moments, you make sure to discuss any quote you use, so that the quote is serving your own argument, rather than the other way around.
Consider the following paragraph:
Sometimes things aren't so easy. "The problem with their plan," psychologist Jane Smith said, "is that they didn't account for the degree to which people are controlled by forces that we can neither prove the existence of nor agree on the function of. I'm talking, of course, about the unconscious, or the subconscious, depending on whether you're Freudian or Jungian about things, which makes a big difference, of course, if you study it closely, though Jung was a student of Freud's, but still, what I'm trying to impress upon you is that sometimes you just don't know" (312).
That paragraph is completely controlled by a quote--the writer hasn't managed to contribute anything to it other than a brief introductory sentence, and it's unclear what the writer wants us to understand from that quote. An example of a writer taking control of the use of a quote might be:
Dogs might salivate at the sound of a bell, but strict behavioral psychology often fails to capture the somewhat more complex behavior of human beings. We know, of course, that people are hungry for food, but other motivations behind human behavior can be maddeningly inscrutable. As Jane Smith notes, strict behaviorists "didn't account for the degree to which people are controlled by forces that we can neither prove the existence of nor agree on the function of" (312). Regardless of whether one prefers Freudian, Jungian, or some other psychology, most people agree that they have experienced moments in which deeper forces seemed to be pushing them to choose one action over another--and those forces aren't as simple as responding to a dinner bell.
All of that stuff--the quote, the paragraphs, etc.--was just made up off the top of our head. What we're trying to show, though, is that in the first example, a somewhat messy and not particularly focused quote had nevertheless been allowed to dominate a paragraph. In the second example, the quote has been trimmed to its useful point, and has been used within a context (and paragraph) controlled by the writer.
It's Quote Week in the Writing Center! Many courses end with some kind of writing assignment that asks you to incorporate information from other sources, and that information can often be delivered in the form of quotes from important texts or knowledgeable authorities. Now that we're in week 7 of spring term, you may be gearing up to write a final paper of that sort, so we'll offer some thoughts on how to effectively incorporate quotations from other sources into your academic papers.
Today's suggestion: Have a good reason for the quotation.
Does the quote strongly support your point or argument? Is it something that can't be paraphrased or summarized effectively in your own words? Consider the following example from a made-up paper about how cats make the best pets:
Jane Smith, a clinical psychologist, puts it best when she says, "Cats are the best pets. They're just better than other kinds of pets" (111).
That quote might seem to support your argument, but it doesn't actually do much. If you, as the writer, have already claimed cats make the best pets, then the only reason to use quotes from other sources would be to extend that argument in greater detail. There's no need for an exact quote there.
You could paraphrase her, though, and save an exact quote for important new information from your source, as in the following:
Jane Smith, a clinical psychologist, claims that cats are better than other pets because "cats are an alien race come to earth, and have much to teach us about our place in the universe" (111).
In that example, an exact quote works well because the information is specific and new.
Here's another example of saving direct quotes for important information:
Before:
"If you really think about it without jumping to conclusions or just saying the first thing that flies into your crazy head," Smith says, "cats require less of an owner's time and energy, and are therefore more convenient as pets--you don't have to feel guilty about not taking them for a walk, because they don't want to go for a walk. My cat just wants to sleep on my couch" (112).
After:
Smith also says that because cats require less maintenance, "You don't have to feel guilty about not taking them for a walk, because they don't want to go for a walk" (112).
In the second version, we've cut or summarized the parts of the quote that aren't distinctive, and saved the direct quote for the words that are interesting and more detailed. The writing is tighter and easier to understand, because the essential information isn't lost in an overlong quote or a glut of irrelevant words.
More tomorrow!