Showing posts with label style. Show all posts
Showing posts with label style. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Active vs. Passive Voice: Part 2 - The Trouble With Passive

Although the previous post discussed situations where using passive voice is useful, using active voice for the majority of your writing is still recommended to maintain readers’ interest and sentence clarity.

Passives become a problem when obscuring the agent obscures your meaning. For instance, you could write:
The governess is misrepresented.
This is a clever passive sentence: first, it sounds fairly natural; second, the “by phrase” is dropped, so the sentence doesn’t immediately look passive. But when writing analysis, it’s important to keep the agent’s identity clear. That example sentence is actually the sentence: “The governess is misrepresented [by someone].” But by whom? By the author? By a critic you’ve read? The identity of the person misrepresenting is probably crucial to the strength of your argument. By using a passive sentence, your meaning becomes uncertain, and your argument unclear. The active version would be:
[The agent] misrepresents the governess.
It’s a small change, but it keeps the language active and your writing clear, which can make a big difference.

Traditionally, many of the social and natural sciences use passive voice in order to emphasize the research, not the researcher. This is because those conducting the research are supposed to be objective and the research should be the sole focus of the report. For example:
We conducted 50 interviews.
50 interviews were conducted.
However, most current science writing guides recommend using active voice whenever possible, even if it means using “I” or “we.” But be aware that some professors prefer the use of passive voice in formal reports. If you are given an example, check to see whether active or passive voice dominates. A quick way to do this is to look for “to be” verbs, such as is, was, am, or were. Although the use of one of these words does not automatically mean the sentence is passive, all sentences with passive construction use these words. You’ll notice in the above example that the passive sentence uses the word “were,” whereas the active sentence does not. Another option is to check in with your instructor or TA to ensure you’re meeting their expectations for the assignment.

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Active Versus Passive Voice: Part 1 - When Passive is Good

The difference between the active versus the passive voice can be confusing. Sometimes this is because people are taught that a passive sentence is somehow evil or, even worse, ungrammatical, because the subject is at the end, but that’s not true. Passive sentences have a subject and are grammatical. What passive sentences hold until the end is what grammarians call “the agent,” by which they mean the entity that took action. Take the following examples:
James wrote the book.
The book was written by James.
The first sentence is active, and its subject is James; the second is passive, and the subject is the book. But James is “the agent” in both sentences—in both cases, he wrote the book.

Now: passive sentences exist for a reason—they aren’t inherently bad. For instance, imagine an English and Liberal Studies major that will be unemployed when he graduates and will have to take an office job. One day he will come into the office early to get some paperwork done. He will enter the little office kitchen, grab the filthy coffeepot to make some coffee…and drop the pot on the floor, shattering it. An honest employee would go to the office manager, admit to breaking the pot, and thank the company for deducting the expense from his next paycheck. Because he has a degree in English or Liberal Studies, however, it will not occur to him to be honest. What he will do is hide the pieces of the broken pot at the bottom of the trash, and then return to his desk. Later, one of his co-workers will stop by, wondering what happened to the coffeepot. He will say:
“Oh, yeah…it was broken.”
The active version of this sentence (“I broke it.”) would incriminate our hero. The beauty of a passive sentence is that he can drop the “by phrase” and instead of saying, “It was broken by me,” he can just say, “It was broken.”

The more honest use of passive sentences stems from situations in which the agent is unknown or nonexistent. For instance:
The law was passed last year.
You could write, “Congress passed the law last year,” but every congressman who didn’t vote for that law will write you an angry letter stating that he didn’t pass that law. By making the sentence passive, you rid yourself of the complex problem of a case in which there is no easily identifiable agent. Also:
She was struck by lightning.
You could easily say “Lightning struck her,” but we don’t often say that, probably because no one really wants to blame lightning—maybe Zeus throws the lightning, or maybe lightning just happens…it’s natural to use the distance of a passive sentence there.

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

Finals Week Hint: The Power of Plain Language, Or: Avoiding the Tower of Babel


Certainly one of the reasons you go to college is to expand your mind. That expansion involves learning new concepts, and new concepts are often delivered through new vocabulary, and new vocabulary can be a challenge to master.

The degree to which you will be expected to use new vocabulary varies from class to class and instructor to instructor. Because we are the Writing Center, though, and because we are trying to help you write during finals week, we will just say this: Don't bluff with those fancy words.

A common difficulty students face in writing for college courses is feeling that they need to use vocabulary and lingo in the same way their instructors use it. If you are in a course where an instructor mentions the ontological issues surrounding notions of the subjective self in our postmodern society, you might feel that when you write a paper for that instructor, you better use the terms "ontological," "subjective," and "postmodern." You might feel this even if you don't quite totally understand what each of those things means.

This can result in two dangerous moments in writing. The first is that you feel you need to write a sentence about ontology, but don't totally know what that is, and so you stare at your computer screen, stuck.

The second dangerous moment is the same as the first, except that you decide to just throw the word ontology into a few sentences anyway, and hope it sounds right. In other words: you bluff.

This never works. Staring at a blank screen doesn't get a paper written. Randomly tossing out some big words incorrectly never impresses an instructor.

So today our suggestion is this: if you're stuck in your paper because you want to use some fancy words but don't know how, just don't use them. If you understand the words and are comfortable using them, then cool, go ahead. But if you don't understand them and don't know how to use them, then just writing in plain language is a much better choice. Using plain language helps you continue writing your paper. Using plain language helps your writing remain clear to your instructor.

Here is The Writing Center bluffing as it composes: The sheer plasticity of postmodern narrative strategies occasions a kind of willy-nilly buffoonery of cross-cultural referencing that can't help but lead one to the recognition that multiple ontologies serve up multiple ideologies in a multiplicity of post-colonial structures, as noted by Foucault and Derrida when they met at the Potsdam Conference at Flushing Meadows.

That doesn't mean anything. Or it only barely means something, and that something is incorrect.

Here is the Writing Center just trying to write something in plain language: Using plain language helps your writing remain clear to your instructor. It doesn't guarantee you will get an A. It guarantees your instructor will understand what you are trying to say, though. And your instructor will appreciate that.