Showing posts with label thesis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label thesis. Show all posts

Friday, February 8, 2008

Focusing Your Topic

By Daneen Bergland

One of the great paradoxes of academic writing is that the narrower your topic, the more you’ll be able to say in your paper. Many students make the mistake of choosing a very broad topic and a vague thesis statement because they are afraid they’ll run out of things to say before they come to the required page length of the assignment. The problem with this tactic is that it prevents the writer from giving in-depth analysis. Or it causes the writer to veer around within the topic without a clear sense of direction. Picture your thesis as a specific destination, a place you’re trying to go to prove your point. The broad topic is a map of the entire country, when you’re really trying to find a street address; whereas, the narrow topic is the city map, full of details, landmarks, and clear directions to get where you need to go.

Narrowing your topic can seem difficult, especially if you’re working on a research paper. You may have found tons of information, all of it interesting and seemingly important. You’ve probably done a lot of work to find all your information and hate the thought of not including all of it in your paper. Take a deep breath and tell yourself whether or not the information you’ve found goes into the paper, it will still be useful as you write your essay and narrow your focus. After all, to the find street you’re looking for, you first need to know what state you’re in.

Here are a couple of ideas taken from Bruce Ballenger’s The Curious Researcher of ways to narrow your topic and find focus. These can be used both at the beginning of your research process, before you’ve started looking, or later in your process, after you’ve done some research and have a good working knowledge of your topic.

Narrow by time, place, story, or person
1. Time. Limit the time frame of your project. Instead of researching the entire Civil War, limit your search to the month or year when the most decisive battles occurred.
2. Place. Anchor a larger subject to a particular location. Instead of exploring “senioritis” at American high schools, research the phenomenon at a local high school.
3. Person. Use the particulars of a person to reveal the generalities about the group. Instead of writing about the homeless problem, write about a homeless man.
4. Story. Ground a larger story in the specifics of a “smaller” one. Don’t write about dream interpretation, write about a dream you had and use the theories to analyze it.

Narrow by relationship
Brainstorm a list of possible relationships between your topic and another.
For instance:
What is the relationship between global climate change and the Internet?
What is the relationship between global climate change and tourism in the U.S.?
What is the relationship between global climate change and advertising?

Once you’ve done some research and taken notes, a good way to narrow your focus is to stand back and look over what you’ve found. Look specifically for patterns or themes that have emerged. Look, too, for possible contradictions or paradoxes. These contradictions are often where you’ll find the most interesting ideas and best opportunities for your own in-depth analysis.

Wednesday, August 1, 2007

WRITING IS LIKE COFFEE


EDITING VS. REVISION

Revision and editing are practically the same thing, right? Dude, where do you get those ideas? Some people may think this (we aren’t necessarily implicating you), but editing and revision are very different processes. Assuming revision is simply changing words, fixing some commas, and moving one paragraph is a dangerous assumption when revising. This is editing. When writing teachers ask you for revision, they’re probably looking for re-vision, that is, to have the vision again. Yes, this sounds scary, but if you do it, you’ll impress your professor. Revision and editing are like coffee. Some days you’re doing pretty okay and maybe only need a tall. Sometimes if you’re feeling shlumpy, you may need a grande. Other days just suck, and you definitely need a venti. If major revision were coffee, it would be the venti.

What does that mean? Well, to start with, you may have to re-think your idea or even change your thesis. In its most radical stages, revision could entail completely rewriting your whole paper. This could happen if you finish your paper and realize the last sentence in your conclusion is really what you want to write. But it might mean that you haven’t clarified your thesis and simply need to rewrite the introduction so it’s coherent. It might mean that you have a super duper introduction, but got bored and rushed through the rest. Your ideas might not be fully developed, so you need to go back and unpack them. (i.e. rewrite these paragraphs.) You may have one awesome paragraph and some muddy ones. Perhaps that awesome paragraph really comes first and the rest just needs to be thrown out and rewritten. Occasionally, revision could be paragraph rearranging if you’ve already rewritten a lot, but we would consider this only a grande. Revision can mean a lot of things, but editing it is not.

What is editing then? If you are sick to death of your paper and can’t possibly think of anything to add or rewrite and find yourself simply fixing comma splices and changing words with a thesaurus, then you’re probably editing without knowing it. Even going through and fixing little lexical ambiguities falls under the heading of editing and proof reading. Things are good. You only need a tall.

Thursday, July 5, 2007

A Working Thesis

WORKING? WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?

Okay, I need to write a paper. That means that I need to know exactly what I’m going to write about, right? Not necessarily. Sometimes it is even better to not worry about this since worrying will often lead to writer’s block. So relax! If you have a rough idea, that’s great. It can be rough, it can be messy, it can even be ugly and nonsensical (well, okay, maybe not nonsensical). The important thing is that you shouldn't be married to any one idea. This is why it is a “working” thesis. It will and should change as you write, but sometimes it is helpful to just have a place holder to trick yourself into thinking you have an introduction, so you can charge ahead and actually get those 5 pages written. It is far less painful to write a messy draft and go back and edit than it is to carefully produce 5 “perfect” pages in one draft.

A working thesis is like a road map, but remember that on a road trip sometime you find the coolest stuff when you take detours, but it is also good to have a map handy in case you get lost. Think of it this way, even if you have 5 crappy pages, hey, they are still 5 pages, which will always be less intimidating than staring at that blank computer screen. Just remember that these pages will need to be revised.